Here’s my recap of “American Idol” of March 16. Please add your thoughts.
The judges strut their stuff onto the big stage and Ryan Seacrest walks down the stairs. Ryan intros the judges and then talks up the fabulous venue before intro-ing the Top 12 Idolers.
The theme tonight is the Rolling Stones, which should prove a challenge for some. I wonder if the Stones are going to show up to mentor the Idolers? No? ‘Kay.
Michael Lynche and “Miss You”: He shows better range than I thought he had, going down low for the soul and up high for the falsetto. Going first is tough, but he brought it and then some. But someone please tell that guy to stop dancing, because the knee-bends just aren’t cutting it.
How cool was it to see Ryan just get right into Simon’s face about his “advice” to Mike? Simon’s always been a jerk, but this season he’s so obviously just killing time until his new show starts next year, I was glad to see Ryan call him out on it.
Didi Benami and “Play With Fire”: I like the arrangement, and she sounded pretty good at first. But she had just a tad bit too much fake angst on her face and that momentary fingerwag was ridiculous. Her ending was weak as she kind of lost the thread.
Casey James and “It’s All Over Now”: He gave the song a country-blues twang, and it’s the best he’s sounded. He seemed to be having a great time on the song, and thank goodness he didn’t put his hair in a ponytail-with-tendrils.
Lacey Brown and “Ruby Tuesday”: This is a great song, but she put too much of a little girl voice on it. Too many notes sounded weak and nervous. And seriously, what was up with that mess of an outfit that looked like she had an old tablecloth wrapped around her?
Andrew Garcia and “Gimme Shelter”: This guy has never reached the level he did during the Hollywood auditions, which is disappointing. He sounded like he couldn’t even hold a note steady and at times went seriously off pitch. Maybe nerves got the best of him. There wasn’t much heart in this performance.
Katie Stevens and “Wild Horses”: She has a good strong voice, but it’s just not been inspiring. On this one, she started off kind of weak and the key sounded a little low for her, but she finished off well, and seemed to feel the song more toward the end.
Tim Urban and “Under My Thumb”: Perhaps not the best song choice to be sung in such a sweet, earnest way by such a babyface. Not for one minute did I believe this guy was going to keep anyone under his thumb. And the reggae? Ugh.
Siobhan Magnus and “Paint it Black”: Best of the night. She not only totally changed up her look this week, she rocked this song. It wasn’t a carbon copy of the original, but her take wasn’t so far off as to be unrecognizable. I liked her jumping an entire octave for the second half of the song, and proving that her hitting that note a few weeks ago was not a fluke. She’s a contender.
Lee Dewyze and “Beast of Burden”: He took it country and it was pretty good. He has a pleasing rasp in his voice (and he reminded me of Everclear’s Art Alexakis) that fit with the genre. It was a little repetitive, but a good performance for him.
Paige Miles and “Honky Tonk Woman”: Weird song choice for a young woman and she sounded really uncomfortable on the verses in her lower register. But she gave it a bluesy feel when she could take it up higher on the refrain. By the end, it had sort of morphed into a Vegasy feel. Just weird all the way around.
Aaron Kelly and “Angie”: He went with his strength, choosing a song that worked and one that he could go all “boy band” on. He brought some character to the middle of the song, he hit all the notes just right and he put some real feeling into the song.
Crystal Bowersox and “You Can’t Always Get What You Want”: Ooooh, walkin’ and strummin’. For some reason, Bowersox has become Adam Lambert for me, with the constantly flipping the bangs back and the too-cool-for-school vibe. She sounds OK, but … I dunno. She’s predictable. Maybe it’s the white girl dreads (if your hair don’t naturally lock, don’t wear ‘em) or the fact that she all but said she’s really above “Idol.” But it was just all right for me.
Siobhan and Aaron won the night for me. What do you think?












